Comments on: The Obese Don’t Know They’re Obese? Give Me a Break

By: ballookey

ballookey — Tue, 11 Apr 2006 21:39:44 +0000

Ugh, you guys are a bunch of jackals. Here’s a link to a photo of my thin, vegan, 162 lb friend. Maybe definitions of “rail thin” vary, but she’s freakin’ thin. I know her weight because we weighed in together for an athletic challenge. Since the scale was accurate for me, I know it was accurate for her. Maybe her healthy diet means her bones are denser. Maybe her athleticism makes her muscles denser. Or here’s a thought, maybe the girls you geeks *allegedly* know are lying about their weight. I have NEVER met a girl who didn’t knock at least 15 to 20 lbs off her actual weight. And the way you guys go on, who can blame them? Anyway, here’s the link:
http://i1.tinypic.com/v741u1.jpg

By: Mister Mustard

Mister Mustard — Tue, 11 Apr 2006 19:06:09 +0000

>>Aren’t Tom Cruise and Michael Jordan classified as obese?

Not sure about Michael Jordan, but Tom Cruise has officially been classified as “deviant”.

Hope this helps.

By: DJ Ruden

DJ Ruden — Tue, 11 Apr 2006 11:45:35 +0000

I’m a smirky thin person and I agree with the eat less, excercise more motto. I workout about 4 times a week, either something like a 2-3 mile run of weightlifting, and I monitor what I eat. I always look at labels to see how much saturation and trans fat I’m getting, try to get a lot of protein, and I try to stay around the 2200 calorie a day recommendation. The system works.

I have obese friends, and dare I say, they do no work out, and when they try, it’s a very pathetic workout. They eat a lot of pizza, chocolate, soda pop, and everything else that’s bad for your body.

While the eat less motto isn’t exactly right- it should be eat healthier. Sure some people have a legit physical condition that doesn’t help or larger bone structure or some other rationalization like that. I still thing the BMI is, for the most part, a good scale. I think some of you are in denial like the rest of the obese world. When a majority are overweight, it blurs your vision or what a normal weight person actually looks like.

By: GregAllen

GregAllen — Tue, 11 Apr 2006 04:01:47 +0000

As for me… I think the dieting industry needs to be banned… or at least have warnings prominently posted on their ads and products.

With failure rates of +95%, one can only conclude that dieting does not work.

Not even the “eat less, exercise more” advice that usually comes from smirky thin people who have no personal experience with chronic fat.

“Eat less. Exercise more.” is as informed as the “Just snap out of it!” advice they used to give the mentally ill.

By: rus62

rus62 — Tue, 11 Apr 2006 02:13:08 +0000

The BMI test is like the BCS in college football, well actually the BCS may be more accurate.

By: Angel H. Wong

Angel H. Wong — Tue, 11 Apr 2006 00:59:54 +0000

Dear John Wooford:

Yes, I’m a dude and yes I like my men on the chunky side so I don’t fit the mainstream gay community obssesed with youth and thin chiseled bodies.

Besides, that BMI scale is just messed up and it only adds to the paranoia/myth that stick thin is beautiful.

By: AB CD

AB CD — Tue, 11 Apr 2006 00:01:31 +0000

Aren’t Tom Cruise and Michael Jordan classified as obese?

By: Zuke

Zuke — Mon, 10 Apr 2006 23:53:04 +0000

189lbs @ 5′7″???? WTF does that look like? The person must be about as round as they are tall. That has to be overweight/obese unless the person is totally muscle-bound (which is much heavier than fat).

I’d agree w/Mister Mustard in that a 162lb woman at 5′8″ could not possibly be ‘rail-thin’ unless she had close to nil body fat % and was pure muscle! Or her head+brain was as big as a pumpkin and weighed 25lbs alone. No freakin way.

My GF is 5′5″ @ 130lbs is an avid runner and she looks about average for her height @ 23% body fat measure. Her BMI of 21.6 is smack in the middle of Normal for her height.

I’m an avid cyclist and weigh 145 @ 5′9″. I would consider myself average-to-thin, but far from a bean-pole. I have 11.5% body fat. BMI of 21.4 is smack in the middle of Normal for my height.

BMI doesn’t look all that whacked IMO…

By: John Wofford

John Wofford — Mon, 10 Apr 2006 23:24:25 +0000

1. Hi, Angel; uh, you are a girl, right? If not then disregard.
2. Thing about genetics; some of us are genetically disposed to be thin, some of us disposed towards corpulence. I’ve fought the fight against obesity all my life, sometime winning, sometimes losing. My most spectacular success was in my late thirties, I lost nearly a hundred pounds, nearly regaining my high school football playing weight. People asked me was I sick, did I have cancer, or was it AIDS? Thin people, those with the correct genetics, don’t have to fight anything, can eat and drink, lay on their backsides and have a good time. These people have zero rights to comment on the physical imperfections of anyone.

By: Angel H. Wong

Angel H. Wong — Mon, 10 Apr 2006 22:09:15 +0000

I love chubby, hairy, balding men; does that makes me a pervert?

By: andrewj

andrewj — Mon, 10 Apr 2006 22:06:09 +0000

I have yet to meet a fat person that believes they’re fat. The giveaway is when you spend a little time with them and hear the comments they make about other fat people.
The explanation is simple. It’s the same mechanism that God uses to protect dumb people from ever knowing how dumb they are.

By: Jetfire

Jetfire — Mon, 10 Apr 2006 21:47:02 +0000

I’m not fat. I’m festively plump.

By: randmeister

randmeister — Mon, 10 Apr 2006 21:16:07 +0000

1) That thumping noise you hear is not a fat person walking; it is popular culture bludgeoning us with what “beautiful” should look like. If someone looks relatively healthy or attractive, I don’t care what size their pants are. If someone is grossly overweight and has no sense of personal hygiene, that is different.

1a) I’ve GOT to lose 5 lbs by the weekend so I can get into my speedo.

1b) Trust me, you don’t want that.

2) I found a related post.

By: blank

blank — Mon, 10 Apr 2006 21:14:05 +0000

I weigh 300 pounds now. I’m a disgusting fat-body. I’m fat and I know it.

However, I used to weight only 150 pounds. That was the lowest weight I’ve ever been in my adult life. I have pictures of when I was that weight…the weight that the BMI chart said I was in the upper-ideal weight category, almost tipping over to obese. When people look at those pictures they say I was WAY too thin. Yes, they say I’m WAY too fat now, but when I was 150 I looked like a skeleton, yet I was almost overweight according to the BMI chart.

So in other words, I think the BMI chart is full of it.

By: Mister Mustard

Mister Mustard — Mon, 10 Apr 2006 21:04:54 +0000

>>One of my best friends is a rail-thin vegan girl
>>about 5′8″ tall. I was astonished to learn she weighs 162 lbs.

She must have lead weights in her shoes then. My gf is 5″9″, and “slim” (not even CLOSE to being “rail thin”) and she weighs about 120. If she put on an additional 50 pounds, she would look like Santa Claus without the beard.

>>the scale puts modestly overweight people at “obese”, which
>>is just wrong.

I’m not so sure about that. I am 6′1 and 212#, which gives me a BMI of 28….”overweight”. I’m in pretty good shape, but I could definitely stand to drop 20 pounds. If I got down to 188, my BMI would be