Toxic Toy Law Threatens Local Businesses – NBCSANDIEGO.COM- msnbc.com

Must now wear new “tested for lead” clothes from Macy’s

This is the most idiotic thing ever to come down the George Bush Pike. Only Walmart, Target and other big stores selling new products can afford this legislation. No mother will be able to buy used clothing for their children or a used children’s book. Technically this mean garage sales will not legally be able to sell these items either. Also the same goes for the Salvation Army stores and Goodwill. Unbelievable. And, note, China has not been shipping clothes with lead in the fabric. It was always about lead paint. How did this legislation come about then? Let’s track it down and I suspect a corrupt politician is behind it.

This legislation also applies to hand-made one-of-a-kind knit clothing. Screw all those grannies in New England who knit mittens.

The Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, passed by Congress in August, goes into effect February 10. Among other things, it mandates all childrens’ products, toys, clothes, books, etc. are tested for toxic lead and phthalates, chemicals used in plastic. Store owners must present a certificate proving the products were tested.

Many small business owners say they can’t afford the testing and will have no choice but to get rid of much of their inventory.

“The cost of digestive testing for lead ranges from $130 to $180 per test on a shirt I am selling for $4.95,” said Gulij.




  1. Improbus says:

    Were from the government and we are here to “protect” you.

  2. Paddy-O says:

    “This is the most idiotic thing ever to come down the George Bush Pike.”

    Actually, The Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, was signed by Bush at the request & urging of the Dem Congress.

    He refused most of these types of wacky bills from the Dem Congress in the past. Can’t wait for Omama to start rubber stamping the new Dem private sector regulations!

  3. Dallas says:

    Well, there are 12 days left in the Bush regime.

    Stay tuned for more idiotic shit but this is nothing in the grand scheme of things. Just another item in the ‘government doing stupid’ pile for Obama for overturn.

  4. George says:

    I find it interesting that liberal dogooders who started the anti-lead hysteria about ghetto kids eating lead paint chips and arguably caused billions of dollars of economic damage to the paint and housing industries (lead paint was a superior product) are now all concerned about business costs.

    If you liberals are so concerned about American business, then why does your president-select want to bankrupt the domestic coal industry and virtually eliminate domestic oil production?

    George Bush is trying to be the kind of Republican you people want. Just remember your mantra. “If it saves the life of just one child…”

    I wonder if Jocelyn Elders is available for service in the Obama administration?

  5. Widgethead says:

    Is there anyway to pass on the certificate, i.e. selling something “as is” or ” caveat emptor” i.e. “not tested to be lead free, user assumes all risks” The whole idea that yard sales and small business will be held accountable to this weird law seems rather unreal. Again the little guy is punished for the errors in judgment of large corporations.

  6. Dallas says:

    #4 Re:
    “…I find it interesting that liberal dogooders who started the anti-lead hysteria..blah blah..”
    Correct. Note that lead poisoning is the reason Bush is mentally retarded. It should have happened earlier.

    “..If you liberals ..blah..why does your president-select want to bankrupt the domestic coal industry and virtually eliminate domestic oil production?..”

    I searching for the “Bankrupt domestic coal industry” bill but I can’t find it. Sorry

    “..George Bush is trying to be the kind of Republican you people want..”
    Yeah right.

  7. eyeofthetiger says:

    This is much like the 2005 bankruptcy act that forced families to pay credit bills over mortgages. Welcome, to your outfit – the wall.

  8. timw077 says:

    Interesting, however, I think someone needs to read the actual law.

    http://www.cpsc.gov/cpsia.pdf

    It is referring to toys *manufactured* after a certain date. The only people this is going to hurt, is manufacturers. They will have to put seals on their products (like they do cribs for other safty laws) saying they meet the CPSIA requirements, and have evidence of 3rd party testing.

    It’s going to be bad for the small time makers, but after reading the law, it isn’t bad idea. Testing is going to increase the price of toys.

    I doubt anyone in their *right mind* would close their thrift shop because of this law.

  9. Mister Mustard says:

    #4 – George

    >>I wonder if Jocelyn Elders is available for
    >>service in the Obama administration?

    Ho ho! An Elders-basher! What, you think that if masturbation is not discussed with high-school students, there will be more left over for you?

  10. Mister Mustard says:

    #2 – Paddy-RAMBO

    >>He refused most of these types of wacky
    >>bills from the Dem Congress in the past.
    >>Can’t wait for Omama to start rubber
    >>stamping the new Dem private sector
    >>regulations!

    Yeah, I’ll have to admit, Merkin did a good job of staving off the Democratic craziness.

    He vetoed bills on stem cell research, Katrina recovery, troop readiness, veterans’ care, childrens’ health insurance, protecing water purity….he was a real ace!

  11. LibertyLover says:

    #10, Don’t forget the farm subsidies, too. Unfortunately, those were overridden by a congress for a grand total exceeding $300B. Most of that money was pork.

    Don’t play holier than thou when both sides of the aisle have their pet projects.

  12. Paddy-O says:

    #10 “he was a real ace!”

    Exactly my opinion.

  13. sargasso says:

    The military and arms manufacturing industries have been administering lead to children for centuries. Obviously, in their context it wasn’t a bad thing.

  14. Mister Mustard says:

    #11 – Loser

    >>Don’t play holier than thou when both sides
    >>of the aisle have their pet projects.

    I’m not playing holier than thou. I’m simply performing my duty to debunk Paddy-RAMBO’s myth that Dumbya has been protecting the country from frivolous legislation foisted on him by “Omama” and his ilk.

    The only thing Dumbya has protected us from (or tried to, as he’s pretty much ineffectual) is legislation that would actually do the country some good.

    And now Paddy-RAMBO shoots back with his snappy rejoinder, verifying that he does indeed consider Dumbya to be “a real ace”.

    Yee-haw! A real ace! We found the one guy in the country (the world?) who doesn’t think Dumbya should be tarred and feathered and forbidden ever to clear brush from his Crawford “ranch” again!

  15. Li says:

    Now that the children are done playing their retrograde and useless game of partisanship, I hope that they are satisfied long enough to discuss the bill itself.

    As far as I can tell, this is an effort by the big toy manufacturers to counter the movement towards cottage industry toy production that was so strengthened by the lead toy scandal of ’07. Frankly, this is clearly built on the model of onerous inspections that killed the local dairy decades ago, but this time the public is more wise and there is a bit more resistance. Just search around a bit and you’ll find several groups against this act, and even better, civil disobedience is easy. All you have to do is sew a glove and give it to a kid, or throw a garage sale. I am a big supported of cottage industry, and we must work against all regulation of this sort to bring about the distributed, decentralized future that can solve so many of our energy, economic and social problems.

  16. meetsy says:

    #8, I guess you can’t really READ!!
    The law is poorly designed and it had an amazingly FAST implementation time. The bugs ain’t out of it.
    The law should be aimed at importers and manufacturers, instead it’s RETROACTIVE to retailers. Go figure. The way the law is written it does say (if I might interpret for you) that goods made prior to Feb 9,2009, cannot be sold, unless testing has occurred (third party testing, mind you…at a cost of between $100 and 400 — and the item is destroyed in the process) and/or a certificate can show that. It is a broad sweeping law, and those caught in the net include: resale stores, ebay, vintage toy stores, doll stores, thrift stores, hand-made items (like sweaters and bibs, or diaper wraps, or toys). Starting in early February Ebay will no longer accept toy sales, or anything for infants..antique or new. The resale and boutique children’s stores are calling Feb 10 National Bankruptcy Day. Even Freecycle is fearing it…because seems the rules are so strict that you can’t legally give these items away…they are hazardous waste (no matter if true or not) and must go to a landfill.
    If you doubt me….try looking up HR4040. Or, read these articles: http://www.flatheadbeacon.com/articles/article/legislating_montana_small_businesses_out_of_business/7197/
    http://www.change.org/ideas/view/save_handmade_toys_from_the_cpsia
    http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-thrift2-2009jan02,0,2083247.story
    The PROBLEM with America is that people only HALF read something then jump to conclusions and just say “oh yeah, that’s fine”. Moronic.

  17. billabong says:

    Remember behind every corrupt pol. there is a businessman corrupting him.

  18. xjonx says:

    There is a very easy and cheap solution. Just mark them all as for “adults only” and let people give them to whom ever they want.

  19. LibertyLover says:

    #15, Now that the children are done playing their retrograde and useless game of partisanship, I hope that they are satisfied long enough to discuss the bill itself.

    I’m non-partisan :-)

    As far as I can tell, this is an effort by the big toy manufacturers to counter the movement towards cottage industry toy production that was so strengthened by the lead toy scandal of ‘07.

    Lobbying groups don’t operate for free. Somebody funds them and somebody get’s paid.

    http://tinyurl.com/9qmmxy

    Here is how much the special interests paid to pass this bill. How much are they getting in return?

  20. Angel H. Wong says:

    More laws protecting mediocre parents..



Bad Behavior has blocked 25315 access attempts in the last 7 days.