Moved BACK to the top until it runs out of steam!

Brick trinity

I was always told that Christianity was a monotheistic religion but I want to challenge that because clearly it is not. First the definitions:

  • No Gods – Atheism
  • One God – Monotheism
  • Two or more Gods – Polytheism

First, I’m not even going through the “Holy Ghost” thing except to say that “Trinity” means 3 and 3 > 1.

Assuming that:

  1. God is a deity
  2. Jesus is a deity
  3. Jesus and God are individuals

Then God and Jesus are two and 2 > 1.

Therefore Christianity is polytheism.

Polytheism isn’t a matter of belief. I personally am a Realist and I don’t believe any of it. However when one objectively classifies religious beliefs based on the number of gods, I’m counting two. Some would count three, but either is greater than one.

The reference is the Bible. According to the stories Jesus and God are two individuals. God was in the Old Testament, Jesus was not. Jesus was born of a virgin, God was not. Jesus addresses God as a separate individual. They have different stories. They have different roles. That talk to each other the way separate people talk.

The bottom line is – they are both deities and they are two individuals. Therefore Christianity is a polytheistic religion.



  1. >>Please stop the racist B.S.

    Oh, I don’t think it’s racist, Scottie, not any more racist than calling someone a “redhead” or saying they’re left-handed.

    It’s all in the eye of the beholder, son. Pointing out obvious differences among the piglets is not racist.

  2. J says:

    #115 Misanthropic Scott

    “MM,

    You’re balancing on the edge yourself.

    I keep telling him that he needs to be more aware of his writings being on the racist edge.

    But instead of thinking he defends it with more racist views.

  3. J says:

    Mr. Mustard

    “Pointing out obvious differences among the piglets is not racist.”

    Oh my fucking god!!!! ARE YOU STUPID???????

  4. pdc says:

    Yes Mr. Mustard, you are a primate too. You just THINK you’re better than other species because you don’t understand them.

  5. >>I keep telling him that he needs to be more
    >>aware of his writings being on the racist edge.
    >>
    >>But instead of thinking he defends it with more
    >>racist views.

    I think you doth protest too much, m’hijito. If you think I’m racist, you don’t know what racism is. Or perhaps you’re one yourself?

  6. bobbo says:

    Politicallyverycorrect—you trying to ride me?

    re #109–“Have you ever thought why Jews are the least liked ethnic group throughout entire world?” /// Taken at face value, I’ve wondered about that myself. I’m thinking its because they actually hold to their religion, don’t compromise, and discourage interfaith marriages? In other words, they are an affront to freedom hating bigots.

    re #113–I wish that were true. Unfortunately, the rational position is when you die, you don’t learn anything. Its a peaceful non-existence, much more human and understandable than any other alternative.

  7. Matthew says:

    Okay people listen up school is in session!

    This discussion may be producing revenue for John, or entertaining for some, or even driving others crazy but it is irrelevant. It doesnt matter that you understand. Why must you understand everything.

    Having said that it is a simple concept that even my kids understand.

    1 thing in three different states.
    H2O-water,steam,ice
    ME-father,son,friend
    YOU-idiot,moron,stoooooopid

    Now for the last one please forgive me I am just kidding. But I hope I have illustrated my point. H2O is the best example, especially if you think about it as a global entity. You may have ice in the arctic as well as water in the ocean at the same time.

    I know it is oversimplified but there you go, take it or leave as you see fit.

  8. <— blatant racist 🙂

  9. Mr Christian says:

    Jesus is God
    John Chapter 1 Verse 1 says:
    In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things were made through Him, and without Him nothing was made that was made. In Him was life, and the life was the light of men. And the light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend it.

    And a few verses later In John Chapter 1 Verse 14 it says:
    And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us, and we beheld His glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth.

    Come out of the darkness my friend, Jesus is standing and waiting for you just to give him a chance, he says:
    Here I am! I stand at the door and knock. If anyone hears my voice and opens the door, I will come in and eat with him, and he with me. To him who overcomes, I will give the right to sit with me on my throne, just as I overcame and sat down with my Father on his throne

    My friend you do not have to be afraid, for I know you are afraid. I love you and if I love you how much more does Christ who is your savior love you?

    I’m sure you have heard:
    For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life. For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved.

    I know Christ because he changed me. For I was once a man of great sin far beyond forgiveness (At least I thought so). But while I was yet a sinner and unclean Jesus revealed himself to me and change me from the inside out. I became a new creation.

    My mind was changed and I did not do it. I could not do it.
    I am still a sinner but cleaned and covered by the blood of Christ’s sacrifice.

    I WAS ONCE LIKE YOU, WORSE THAN YOU, BECAUSE I KNEW THE TRUTH AND CHOSE TO IGNORE IT.

    “For all have sinned, and fall short of the glory of God.” (Romans 3:23)

    Jesus Christ came to save the lost that is me and that is you.

    When we pray, asking God for the gift of salvation, we’re exercising our free will to acknowledge that we believe in Him. That demonstration of faith pleases God, because we have freely chosen to know Him.

    Give him a chance just pray this prayer of salvation with me and if you are sincere God knows and he will hear you.

    Pray this with me:
    God I realize I fall short and I realize I need a savior because my sins have separated me from you. I am truly sorry, I repent and turn from my sinful ways and turn toward you. Please forgive me and help me to avoid sin in the future. I do not know what is going to happen to me when I die and I want to know. I believe Jesus died for me and you raised him from the dead and he makes the way for me to be reconciled to you. Jesus I don’t know you, I don’t even know if you are real. I don’t understand what you are all about but I want to know. Jesus I invite you to be the Lord of my life. Cleanse me and make me a new creation and teach me your ways. I accept your sacrifice on the cross for me. I pray In Jesus’ name, Amen.

    Friends, if you pray this prayer with a sincere heart Jesus heard you and he has given you a new life. You are now a follower of Jesus. This is a fact, whether or not you feel any different.
    Do not worry that you do not understand everything; it will come to you in time. God’s Holy Spirit is our teacher, our helper, our counselor, our comforter, and much more.
    The Bible tells us that your eternal salvation is secure, it says:
    “That if you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.” (Romans 10:9)
    First find a bible and read the gospel of John in the New Testament.
    Then find a good church in your area that teaches the bible. There will be someone there to answer your questions.

    God bless you in this Christmas season. If you prayed to receive Christ into your heart this Christmas will be special and blessed for you indeed.

  10. PoliticallyVeryCorrect says:

    #118 Bayou Rabbi – well, just for the fact that you are religious jew, and most likely another leech on the christian or islamic society, you are the “cloven hoof scum” to me as well 🙂 You may call it antisemitism as well, I won’t care either 😉

    #115 you are a hopeless idiot, gosh! (you gotta be some liberal fat american, dont lie! 😉 )
    Please:
    Tell Mister Bayou Rabbi or Mister Christian Mustard that “we all are the same” and lets see which one of them will eliminate you first 😀

  11. Jim says:

    MISTER MUSTARD!!! read comment #63 and answer please.

  12. Ah the water analogy…wait, wait, I have one…Jesus crucified could make him – a book end, a funny paperweight, a hood ornament. Did I get the idea of the trinity right?

  13. politicallyVeryCorrect – Thank you for your complements. Anytime I am considered different and not associated with petty christians I feel like I am doing something right 🙂

  14. J says:

    Mr. Mustard

    “I think you doth protest too much, m’hijito.”

    Yeah you wish. All you Christians like little boys don’t you? LOL Just kidding but you left that one out there.

    “If you think I’m racist, you don’t know what racism is.”

    Merriam Webster’s

    racism – a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race

    Yeah I guess I do.

    Your language here is very telling of your disregard of others ethnicity

    “Or perhaps you’re one yourself?”

    Hah! I wont even dignify that.

  15. PoliticallyVeryCorrect says:

    #132, nah, you mistaken menorrah with crucifix 😀

  16. PoliticallyVeryCorrect says:

    #133 your welcome and it is the same – but opposite – here. I would barf if you’d call me christian (or muslim or buddhist or – bleh! – jewish) 😀

  17. And for more proof concerning the lie that is jesus check out my link. It’s amazing how a religious Jew can prove that jesus was a joke and provide proof for others Jews like me, so that they can not only slam the door in an evangelists face but also make his question his “god” 🙂

  18. bobbo says:

    #127–thats funny as if an analogy explains anything===it doesn’t. It is just a layer of BS to cover up something that cannot be proven.

    Got proof–show it so others can replicate it.

    Got no proof–use an analogy and act superior.

  19. Cripes. I think I’m going to give Marc “Linux” Perkel his own sub-blog for all the comments he gets with these posts.

  20. PoliticallyVeryCorrect says:

    #134, then by your definition, the jewish religion is pure racism 😀

  21. J says:

    Matthew #127

    You make the most compelling argument of all in this Blog.

    You see Mr. Mustard Just because you are Christian doesn’t require you to be stupid.

    Matthew I, not being religious, have studied many religions in school. I personally understand your position on the trinity. I also don’t care. lol If that is what you believe that is what you believe. I am ok with that as long as you don’t try to force it into the schools or into public policy.

  22. #140, If I say that I am concerned with only Jews, and protecting Jews from christians, then you do the math 🙂

  23. >>Oh my fucking god!!!! ARE YOU STUPID???????

    Heh heh. Panties in a twist again?

  24. PoliticallyVeryCorrect says:

    #137 here youre wrong.
    your “proofs” are proofs for your kind only, same as chrsitian’s proof are good for christians and islamic proofs for muslims.

    Mankind have yet to see someone’s proof (or disproof) to be acceptable universally without any doubts 😀

  25. OMG says:

    Ok… want to get a bunch of comments on a blog post? Write something crazy about any religious topic and wait for the flood of comments, and then say to the boss… Look how much traffic I’ve generated for you… Ka..ching!!!

    This is after all Mr. Dvorak’s (I hate Apple) blog right?

  26. #145 you are right. The christian “god” jesus is a lie and when you write about it people tend to go crazy…it’s hard to break free of the lie that is christ, but some of us work to speak the truth.

  27. J says:

    Mr. Mustard

    “Heh heh. Panties in a twist again?”

    No I can’t believe how fucking stupid you are. You have been told that your comments are either racist or on the edge of racism. Instead of correcting it you continue to post racist statements and use racist statements to defend you other racist statements. Too me that is just plain fucking stupid.

  28. Jimbo, I have no interest in arguing religion with you. Are you a Jehovah’s Witness? A Christadelphian? LDS?

    In any case, you’re free to believe as you wish, as am I.

  29. >>You have been told….

    I’ve been told a lot of things. Many of them I don’t believe. And when a VeryPoliticallyCorrect evangelist tells me I’m a racist because I state the fact that “being a Jew” is an ethnic as well as religious classification, I blow it off completely.

    Consider yourself blown off. Get a grip.

  30. J says:

    Mr Mustard

    Why don’t you and Mr. Fusion start a clan. You both seem to have similar views. He thinks slavery isn’t an issue when it is only 10% of the population and you think it is ok to you racist terms to defend you religious position.

    First. You don’t need to defend your religious position. You can believe what ever you want. Just don’t push it on to others.


5

Bad Behavior has blocked 10746 access attempts in the last 7 days.